Skip to main content

Why dark roast isn’t always the best: Understanding the different coffee roasts

Every coffee roast, explained

classifying coffee roasts pexels goumbik 296285 649c5e
Lukas / Pexels

Even after coffee beans are collected from the trees they grow on, they still have a long journey before they’re packaged and ready to consume. These beans are stable but not yet ready for coffee drinkers to enjoy. Coffee beans must go through a roasting process that completely transforms the flavor of your final cup of coffee.

“Coffee roasts” refers to the different methods of roasting coffee to develop its flavor. The coffee roasting process brings out the flavor and aroma of the beans, yielding coffee roasts that differ based on the time and heat at which beans are roasted. This is where the classic coffee roasts you know and love, such as dark roast coffee, come into play. Even beyond the classics, such as light or dark roast coffee, you may stumble upon other less-familiar coffee roast types that leave you questioning what makes them unique. Here’s your guide to classifying coffee roasts,

Recommended Videos

Light roast coffee

One coffee bean close-up
Lukas / Pexels

Also known as blonde roast coffee, light roast coffee is roasted at a lower temperature and for a shorter time than other coffee roasts. Visibly, light-roasted coffee beans have a lighter color than other coffee beans and do not have the oil found on other types of roasted beans.

Generally, light roast coffee is lightly toasted at 350 to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. As a result, its flavor is quite acidic, with a light and fruity taste. Typically, coffee roasters will pull these beans out of the roaster at the first “popping” or crack noise, whereas other beans are roasted much longer than this.

Light roast variations

Cuban coffee
Sedanur Kunuk / Pexels

Some brands may refer to their “light roast” coffee as a light city roast, half city roast, or even New England roast. These all fall into the light roast category, cooked to about 375 to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. While these can vary a bit depending on the roastery, each coffee roast has a bright, delicate, fruity, and floral taste. If you like a mild and light cup of coffee, any of these coffee roasts will appeal to you.

The cinnamon roast is also part of the light roast coffee family. This is the lightest of the light roast coffee, barely at 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Cinnamon roast coffee is very acidic, producing a citrusy and sour flavor. You may not have heard of this roast, even if you’re an avid coffee connoisseur. This is because cinnamon roast is not very popular in retail environments, as it is acidic. Most coffee drinkers find traditional light roast coffee more enjoyable.

Medium coffee roasts

Cup of black coffee
Samer Dabou / Pexels

Medium-roasted coffees are perfectly balanced, not too dark yet also not too mild. They are medium-brown in color and have a slightly sheened texture. A medium roast is roasted at about 400 to 440 degrees Fahrenheit until just before the second crack (usually about 10 to 15 minutes). The longer roasting time compared to light roast coffee gives it a more balanced flavor, with chocolate, fruit, and brown sugar notes.

You’ll likely find other variations and names for medium roast coffee when shopping, such as American roast or breakfast roast. However, breakfast roast, as some roasteries use it, can mean light roast or a mix of light and medium roasts. American roast is usually roasted at 410 degrees Fahrenheit.

Medium-dark coffee roasts

cup of long black coffee
M. Rinandar Tasya / Shutterstock

When you want something slightly bolder than medium roast coffee, yet not quite dark roast coffee, there are medium-dark roasts. Medium-roast coffees fall somewhere between the two roasts and have a fuller body and lower acidity compared to light and medium-roast coffees. The beans appear slightly darker than medium roast coffee bean, with a dark brown color and a slightly oil sheen on the beans.

Medium-dark coffee, known as city roast, is roasted at around 425 degrees Fahrenheit. Some coffee lovers classify it as a medium roast, but others classify it as a medium-dark roast. Alternatively, a full city roast coffee is roasted at 435 to 440 degrees Fahrenheit. Full city coffee stops just before the second crack but has a darker color and more oil than traditional city roast coffee.

Dark roast coffee

dark roast coffee
Jaspert Anrijs / Pexels

Dark roasts are roasted at much higher temperatures and for longer than light and medium roasts. The long roasting time turns the beans a very dark brown or almost black color and leaves them with a shiny, oily surface. Dark roast coffees have a very bold, rich, and smoky flavor with notes of warm spices and dark chocolate. Due to their rich flavor, dark roast coffees are most commonly used to make espresso drinks.

Dark roast coffee beans are roasted at 430 and 450 degrees Fahrenheit. The long roasting process causes coffee beans to lose moisture and absorb heat, leaving them with their dark color. Other names for dark roast coffees include high roast, continental roast, espresso roast, Italian roast, french roast, or Viennese roast. Each of these dark roasts may be roasted at slightly different times or at varying temperatures, but all will have a robust flavor.

Emily Caldwell
Emily is an accomplished freelance journalist with over seven years of experience in food, beverage, health, fitness, and…
Why does coffee make me sleepy? How caffeine can leave you feeling tired
What to do when coffee has the opposite effect
man who is tired

Coffee is the most popular stimulant in the U.S., consumed by nearly 75% of Americans. As a long-time coffee drinker, there's no doubt that it's my favorite stimulant (even if its effects are unnoticeable due to my crazy high caffeine tolerance). Even though I crave coffee's taste, with a slight bitterness and light sweetness, based on taste alone, I sometimes reach for coffee simply for a major boost of energy from its caffeine content.

At times, I feel perkier after a cup of coffee, but there are also times I'm struggling to stay awake. This phenomenon has left me questioning," Why does coffee make me sleepy?" If you've felt that random wave of tiredness hit you after consuming caffeine, you might have asked yourself this question, too. The question of how coffee and tiredness are interrelated can get confusing, especially given coffee's well-known reputation as a drink that keeps you awake. Here are a few reasons you might feel tired after drinking coffee.
Why does coffee make me sleepy?

Read more
Brew the perfect cup: 8 best coffees for French press lovers
Brew exceptional french press coffee
french press

The manual French Press coffee brewing method is a tried and true brewing method, delivering exceptional coffee with minimal effort. Through the immersion method which steeps coffee grounds into a hot water, the flavor of beans is fully extracted while allowing coffee to retain it's essential oils for a richer, more complex aroma than coffee made with a filter.

However, the key to brewing exceptional coffee with a French Press extends beyond the brewing technique. The type and quality of coffee beans you use can make the difference between a subpar cup of coffee and an exceptional one. While you can use any type of coffee roast for French Press brewing, medium to dark roasts are typically best for this type of brew. To help guide you, we've compiled a list of the best coffee for French Press brewing.

Read more
Can you make great coffee in a single serve? Klatch Coffee’s answer
Is there a better option than K-Cups?
Crazy Goat coffee

While K-Cups can be appealing to coffee drinkers who value convenience at home or in the office, they're not the right choice for everyone. Although it's a fast and easy way to prepare a single cup of coffee, there are a few downsides to the system — namely that K-cup pods can be difficult to recycle (and while refillable pods exist, that depends on the user choosing that option, which isn't always a given considering quick and convenient are two of the main appeals of the system). We interviewed Klatch Coffee's expert roaster, Heather Perry, to learn more about the specialty roaster's approach to single-serve coffee.
Klatch Coffee's single-serve coffee alternatives

Klatch Coffee's single-serving Bruvi pods make it easy to enjoy high-quality, specialty coffee wherever you are. The brand has partnered with a few select providers who share their vision, one of which is Bruvi.
"Bruvi is an improved pod coffee system with a couple of unique features," Perry said. "First is taste and quality; the proprietary brewing system brews to the same high standards as specialty coffee roasters like Klatch Coffee, including adjusting the brewing parameters to match our brewing recipe. That’s why premium coffee from roasters like Klatch is offered on the Bruvi platform. Second, Bruvi’s B-Pods are enzyme-infused and designed to be tossed in the trash, making them guilt-free. B-Pods degrade faster in the landfill without leaving microplastics behind."
It’s also worth noting that for coffee drinkers who only want a single cup at a time, single-serve brewing can be more efficient on resources like water, coffee, and energy. Pre-portioned coffee doesn’t spill, and machines only heat the water needed for a single cup. There’s no waste from discarding leftover coffee from a large pot.

Read more